Back to the drawing board on Emergency Services Levy reform

The Committee has recommended that any levy replacing the ESL should be “spread across the community in an equitable way”, after finding there was no clear consensus in support of any of the five property-based models proposed by NSW Treasury.

Property Council NSW Executive Director Katie Stevenson said the recommendations reflected the long-standing position argued by the Property Council throughout the reform process.

“Emergency services protect every person, every community and every part of our economy, so it follows that everyone should contribute fairly to funding them,” Ms Stevenson said.

“Our emergency services do extraordinary work protecting lives, homes and communities across NSW, and they deserve a funding system that is secure, sustainable and built to last.

“That’s exactly why we need to get this reform right – a service that benefits everyone should be funded in a way that is fair to everyone.

“Ours was never an argument against reform, it was an argument for getting reform right and we’re pleased that the committee has heard that call loud and clear.

Ms Stevenson said the Government’s five options risked shifting too much of a growing bill onto property owners and businesses.

“The Committee has recognised the fundamental principle we have been arguing for: the cost needs to be spread equitably across the community and particularly that industrial and commercial owners should not be adversely impacted by a replacement levy,” Ms Stevenson said.

“We can’t improve insurance affordability by transferring a disproportionate share of the cost onto the businesses that employ people, the shopping centres people visit, the warehouses that keep goods moving or the projects delivering the homes NSW desperately needs,” Ms Stevenson said.

The Committee also noted the vital role of the Independent Pricing and Regulatory Tribunal (IPART) in making sure the savings from any new ESL levy are passed on in full and that customers are not overcharged for insurance premiums.

“It’s important to recognise that moving the levy off insurance doesn’t make the cost disappear – the real policy question and the one we’ve been focused on has always been where that bill lands next,” Ms Stevenson said.

The Committee’s report highlighted evidence from the Property Council that sharing emergency services funding between consolidated revenue, emergency service users and landowners would provide a “fairer and more sustainable” approach.

“The Committee points to a practical pathway forward, namely progressively reducing the existing levy and increasing the contribution from consolidated revenue, without imposing new taxes.

“That is exactly the kind of broader, fairer approach we have been calling for. Emergency services are a fundamental public service, and their funding should reflect that,” Ms Stevenson said.

Ms Stevenson said the Property Council had taken its concerns beyond Parliament through a statewide public information campaign explaining the proposed reforms and asking the community what a fair system should look like.

“The campaign reached more than 2 million people and generated more than 9.6 million views and 337,000 engagements over 10 weeks.

“Of more than 1,280 poll participants, 79 per cent said they were concerned property owners could be left carrying more of the cost and 77 per cent said the cost of emergency services should be shared fairly across NSW.

“The community understood this very quickly: if emergency services are there for all of us, we need a funding system that is fair to all of us,” Ms Stevenson said.

“The Committee’s report gives us an opportunity to reset this reform and get it right.

“We stand ready to work constructively with the Government and Treasury on a new model that takes pressure off insurance without putting unfair and unsustainable burdens on other sectors.

“Let’s reform the ESL, but let’s make sure the replacement is genuinely fair, sustainable and built to last,” Ms Stevenson said.

/Public Release. View in full here.