Briefed by International Criminal Court on Proceedings concerning Libya, Security Council Divided over Judicial Body’s Role

Nearly 16 years after referring the situation in Libya to the International Criminal Court, the Security Council heard today that the upcoming trial of a former Libyan prison official marks a step towards justice for victims of atrocities, as its members clashed over sanctions, judicial independence and the Court’s legitimacy.

“It is with regret that I am compelled to address you remotely,” said Mame Mandiaye Niang, the Court’s Acting Prosecutor, noting that he is doing so “because of the sanctions imposed by the United States Government”. Nevertheless, despite those measures and other political pressures, he said that the Court continues to deliver results for victims in Libya.

On 16 July, one of the Court’s pre-trial chambers confirmed 17 war crime charges against Khaled Mohamed Ali el Hishri – including murder, torture, persecution and rape – relating to abuses at Mitiga Prison in Tripoli. Recalling testimony from survivors, he quoted one victim: “I never really left the prison.”

The confirmation of charges marked an important step towards accountability, he said, with proceedings against Mr. El Hishri scheduled to begin in May 2027. Investigators are also pursuing crimes committed between 2014 and 2020 and abuses against migrants.

Stressing the importance of partnerships, he highlighted cooperation with Libyan authorities, civil society and international investigators. Such collaboration, he said, demonstrates that international justice can produce “tangible results” even under difficult circumstances.

However, the Acting Prosecutor expressed concern that another Court suspect, Osama Elmasry Njeem, reportedly remained free to meet officials and others despite information about his detention in Libya. He also highlighted cooperation with Dutch authorities investigating human trafficking, hostage-taking, extortion and sexual violence linked to Libya. Sharing evidence across jurisdictions, he stressed, has helped advance national proceedings and demonstrated the importance of complementarity between international and domestic courts.

Turning to sanctions against the Court, he warned that attempts to weaken the institution ultimately threaten victims’ prospects for accountability. “I will only stop when justice is done,” he quoted another survivor as saying. That determination should guide international efforts to ensure that victims of atrocities can confront those responsible and obtain justice, he said.

Many Voice Support for Court, United States Rejects Non-Consensual Jurisdiction

In the ensuing discussion, Council members were divided over the Court’s role in Libya. Several welcomed progress towards accountability and condemned sanctions against the institution, while others said that the Court is politicized, commits jurisdictional overreach and undermines national sovereignty.

Denmark’s representative reaffirmed her country’s unwavering support for the Court, condemning United States sanctions and restrictions preventing the Court’s officials from briefing the Council in person. “We reiterate that continued support for the Court’s efforts to ensure accountability is essential to secure justice for victims, and ultimately, to achieve lasting reconciliation in Libya,” she stressed.

Similarly, France’s representative welcomed the forthcoming trial of Mr. El Hishri as a milestone for victims. “This is a strong signal to the Libyan people that those responsible for the most serious crimes will have to be held accountable,” he said. Highlighting growing cooperation with Libyan authorities, he observed: “The [Court] is not acting against Libyan sovereignty, but, rather, for its restoration – not against the Libyan Government, but with its assistance.”

The representative of the United Kingdom also opposed sanctions against the Court, warning: “Measures which impede the Court in carrying out its work risk undermining our collective efforts to secure accountability for the most serious international crimes.” He, too, welcomed the upcoming trial of Mr. El Hishri, underscoring the gravity of charges involving murder, torture, persecution, rape and sexual violence.

His counterpart from the United States, however, reiterated his country’s “unequivocal opposition” to the Court asserting jurisdiction over countries without their consent. “The core US objections to the [Court] have remained the same for nearly three decades,” he said, while adding that the Court “has the opportunity to change course”. Nevertheless, he emphasized the need for accountability for serious human rights abuses in Libya, including violations committed in detention centres.

Moscow Urges Council to Withdraw Referral, Others Emphasize National Ownership

The Russian Federation’s representative went further, stating that the politicized Court fails to deliver justice. “The [Court] not only made no contribution to achieving peace and justice in Libya; it serves the interest of a narrow group of Western States,” she said. On the trial of Mr. El Hishri, she emphasized that the Court overlooked the 2011 intervention in Libya by the North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO) and selectively prosecuted some while ignoring alleged abuses by European authorities.

“All responsibility shifts exclusively to small perpetrators and intermediaries from countries of the Global South,” she said, urging the Council to withdraw its referral of the Libyan situation.

Other speakers emphasized the importance of national ownership, with China’s representative urging international partners to assist Libya in strengthening its own institutions while avoiding interference or external pressure. Similarly, Bahrain’s delegate underscored the importance of respecting Libya’s judicial sovereignty and strengthening national institutions. Somalia’s representative stressed: “Libyan leadership in addressing justice must take precedence, supported by regional and African mechanisms – including in addressing cross-border challenges and protecting vulnerable populations, such as migrants.”

Pakistan’s representative, while noting that his country is not party to the Rome Statute , reaffirmed its strong commitment to credible and impartial accountability for serious international crimes. The representatives of the Democratic Republic of the Congo and Panama further commended the Court’s progress on cases regarding Libya, highlighting improvements in evidence-collection and engagement with civil society, survivors and women human rights defenders.

Victims Must See Justice

Meanwhile, several Council members focused on translating that judicial progress into tangible justice for victims. Liberia’s representative welcomed improved cooperation between the Court and Libyan authorities, but warned that outstanding arrest warrants “nevertheless remain unexecuted”. He urged Libya to respond to the Court’s requests for assistance and stressed that migrant survivors must be able to participate safely in judicial proceedings.

“Justice should be victim-centred, and efforts towards political stability must not – under any circumstances – come at the expense of rendering justice, which is the basis for the rule of law and national reconciliation,” added Greece’s representative. Colombia’s representative also emphasized the need to protect witnesses and keep victims at the centre of the process “given the proximity of the trial”.

The representative of Latvia, Council President for November, spoke in her national capacity to welcome “tangible progress in the fight against impunity”. Yet, she warned that progress in The Hague must be matched by cooperation on the ground. Expressing concern that Osama Elmasry Njeem remains at liberty, she urged Libyan authorities to provide information needed to execute the Court’s arrest warrant.

/Public Release. View in full here.