Kyoto, Japan — Though we may fight with our siblings sometimes, for most people a sibling is a constant companion throughout childhood and often for one’s entire life. Yet this is not always the case in the animal kingdom: in some species, siblings engage in serious fights that can even escalate to fratricide. They may be genetically related, but must also compete for limited resources.
Sibling conflict — as it is known in evolutionary biology — has been studied extensively, particularly in birds, but few comparative studies have examined why it evolves in some species and not in others, or how it manifests itself over time. To address these questions, a team of researchers from Kyoto University investigated sibling aggression in cichlid fish inhabiting two ancient lakes in Africa.
“During my dives in Lake Tanganyika, I noticed that siblings in some species seemed to get along peacefully, while those in others fought frequently,” says corresponding author Shun Satoh. “This simple observation led me to wonder why such differences exist.”
The researchers headed to Lake Tanganyika in Zambia and Lake Malawi in Malawi, two lakes renowned for the adaptive radiation — or rapid diversification — of their cichlid fish inhabitants. Using underwater cameras, the team recorded the behavior of 1,892 individual juvenile cichlids from 52 species. They documented aggressive behavior towards siblings as well as body size, feeding behavior on the lake bottom versus in the water column, and the density of juveniles around their nests.
Results indicated clear sibling conflict, but only in the Lamprologini tribe of cichlids endemic to Lake Tanganyika. The researchers then narrowed their focus to this tribe and conducted a phylogenetic comparative analysis with data collected from 1,312 individuals across 30 species, and investigated the sociological factors associated with sibling aggression.
This analysis revealed sibling conflict to be far more frequent in species that rely on food resources found on the bottom of the lake. In contrast, the team observed that conflict tends to decrease as the density of juveniles around the same nest increases. Furthermore, in species where only mothers care for their offspring, juveniles rely more heavily on food resources found on the lake bottom and sibling conflict becomes more intense, while sibling aggression was not observed in species where both parents cooperate and juveniles can venture into the water column.
While the team found no clear difference in conflict levels between group-living and non-group-living species, sibling conflict tended to be more frequent during early development for group-living species, and later in development for non-group-living species.
These findings are consistent with the observation that sibling conflict reflects a balance between the benefits of defending food resources on the lake bottom and the costs of driving away siblings in crowded environments. This study also highlights the role that parental care strategies may play in shaping sibling conflict, and ultimately demonstrates that sibling conflict is shaped by ecological conditions as well as social organization.