Embassies already play a key role in international relations. Could they also help drive meaningful change in human rights?
According to the Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade, Australia has a network of over 120 embassies over five continents. Each play a critical role in maintaining diplomatic relations, facilitating international cooperation and act as key liaisons between governments.
A new white paper, co-authored by UNSW Law & Justice Professor and Australian Human Rights Institute Associate Lucas Lixinski and Lucas Carlos Lima, Professor of International Law at the Federal University of Minas Gerais, suggests embassies can play a more active role in human rights diplomacy, rather than simply passing along information between governments.
Although the white paper examines embassies in San José, Costa Rica and their relationship with Inter-American Court of Human Rights, Prof. Lixinski says the findings could help countries like Australia think about how diplomats can play a bigger role in contributing to human rights. This engagement could include working with other countries and international bodies human rights issues.
“Human rights aims to change people’s lives. We can do that through directly shaming and ordering states to change their ways and their laws. But sometimes a softer touch, via more diplomatic channels, can be effective, and even pave the way for deeper legal transformation,” he says.
Interviews conducted for the white paper show how that could play out for embassies. Prof. Lima says embassies in San José described how they want to be a “friendlier face”, rather than take a defensive approach. They also highlighted how they want to help officials such as universities and journalists at home understand the court cases in other countries.
The hidden role of diplomats
Despite their potential role to advance human rights, diplomats’ contribution to this area of work is largely invisible.
Prof. Lima says this is partly because international laws and institutions often treat countries as a single entity, overlooking the contribution that embassies make and treating them no more than communication channel.
“But the state is not a monolith, it is made of all sorts of different entities that coordinate themselves to reach common goals,” he says.
Where Australia stands
Prof. Lixinski points to Australia’s Permanent Mission in Geneva as an example of human rights diplomacy in practice. The mission represents Australia at the United Nations and the World Trade Organisation in Geneva and is separate from the Australian embassy in Switzerland.
“Unlike most countries in Latin America that have human rights bodies with jurisdiction spread across San José, Washington DC and Geneva, all the bodies that oversee Australia’s human rights record are in one city,” he says.
“It is also a city where there are a lot of other international organisations, which justifies a bigger and more effective diplomatic mission.”
Prof. Lixinski says the Permanent Mission puts Australia in a “very good position” to contribute to international human rights discussions. Diplomats based in Geneva can share insights on how Australia can improve its human rights as well as help the UN achieve its vision of good human rights practices.
“Australian diplomats in the mission get to be more and more specialised,” he says.
But it’s not just the international contributions that matter. The work of diplomats and embassies can also influence human rights laws and policies in Australia.
Prof. Lixinski points to Toonen v Australia, a landmark case considered by the United Nations Human Rights Committee that decriminalised consensual sex between men in Tasmania. The decision led to legal reform across Australia, strengthening protections for LGBTQIA+ people.
How embassies can move beyond being a ‘post office’
The white paper makes seven recommendations of how the role of embassies in San Jose can be expanded. Prof. Lima says six could apply to Australia’s Permanent Mission in Geneva.
One opportunity is to make better use of diplomats’ communication skills. This includes creating specialist human rights roles, building networks and sharing good human rights practices with other countries and ensuring that the Mission’s human rights work isn’t lost when diplomats move to another post.
Embassies could also help strengthen understanding between governments and international human rights bodies. By showcasing Australian cultural perspectives, diplomats could help these organisations better understand the communities affected by human rights issues.
Another recommendation focuses on creating opportunities for Australian graduates and professionals to work with United Nations human rights bodies. They could then bring their experience and knowledge back to Australia, helping the country meet its international human rights obligations.
Prof. Lixinski says a more strategic approach to diplomatic engagement could also help Australia better understand and respond to recommendations from United Nations human rights bodies.
“There is a lot to be said about using embassies not just to make states look good on the international scene, but also as catalysts for the transformation that human rights law and institutions can make happen for people on the ground in Australia.”