The Albanese Government’s dramatic backdown today on its Working Holiday Maker visa restrictions is an admission that its original proposals were fundamentally flawed and completely misjudged.
However, there is no denying the revised arrangements are still a cut on last year’s figures.
Nationals Leader, Senator Matt Canavan, said the announcement by Immigration Minister Tony Burke confirmed precisely what The Nationals and regional industries had warned from the outset.
“The Coalition and industry stakeholders warned very clearly that Labor’s original proposed restrictions would threaten regional jobs, businesses and agricultural production,” Senator Canavan said.
“These are industries that depend on Working Holiday Makers to fill genuine workforce shortages, especially in regional communities where finding enough local workers is already a serious challenge.
“Instead of consulting with and listening to those industries before making its original announcement, Labor pressed ahead with poorly conceived restrictions and created completely unnecessary uncertainty for regional employers and Working Holiday Makers.”
Shadow Minister for Home Affairs and Immigration, Senator Jonno Duniam, said unlike Labor, the Coalition remained committed to reducing overall migration to sustainable levels, while ensuring that Australia’s immigration system responded to genuine workforce needs.
“Australia needs a migration program that reflects our housing and infrastructure capacity, and that means abandoning Labor’s approach and actually recognising the particular needs of regional communities and industries that rely on seasonal and temporary workers,” Senator Duniam said.
Shadow Minister for Agriculture, Fisheries and Forestry, Darren Chester, added the Coalition has a clear and constructive alternative policy – announced last month – which will encourage Working Holiday Makers to travel to where they are needed most.
“Labor’s backflip today doesn’t change the fact farmers are still being asked to plan their harvest workforce around a chook raffle,” Mr Chester said.
“Labor clearly doesn’t understand how heavily agriculture relies on Working Holiday Makers. Any cut to the raw numbers will hit farmers harder than other industries, because the seasonal nature of harvest work means growers depend on these workers being available at the right place and the right time.
Shadow Minister for Tourism, David Littleproud, slammed the Albanese Government for its shambolic handling of Australia’s migration system, saying that Labor’s decision to target the backpacker intake was hopelessly misguided and a disgrace.
“Backpackers are a crucially important part of the economic and social fabric of regional Australia, especially in tourism,” Mr Littleproud said.
“These are the workers who change the beds in our motels, who pour the beers in our pubs, and who fill critical shortages when local workers aren’t available. By doing the jobs that Australians won’t do, they are essential to strengthening the productivity of our nation.
“Despite the humiliation of today’s backdown, Labor’s decision to persist with a rebranded ballot system is shameful. This Government will base our migration system on a raffle, rather than on merit, and this will harm Australia’s reputation as a tourism destination and deter backpackers by adding uncertainty to their visa conditions.