Justice Committee calls for changes to regulations to make affordable legal services more accessible, following evidence from Manchester Justice Hub director Dr Philip Drake
Evidence from a Manchester academic has helped to shape a parliamentary recommendation aimed at making legal services more accessible and affordable.
Dr Philip Drake, Senior Lecturer in Law and Director of The University of Manchester’s Justice Hub, gave evidence to the House of Commons Justice Committee as part of its inquiry into access to legal services.
The Committee’s new report draws directly on Dr Drake’s evidence in its call for a fundamental review of how legal services are regulated.
The report’s third recommendation calls for a new regulatory framework which:
- Simplifies the structure of legal services regulation, potentially through a single legal services regulator.
- Focuses regulation more closely on the activities being undertaken and the risks to consumers, rather than primarily on professional titles and organisational structures.
- Reviews barriers to providing low-cost, unbundled and not-for-profit legal services, including compliance requirements which could be simplified without weakening essential consumer protections.
- Supports responsible innovation and the use of technology in delivering legal services.
Removing barriers to affordable legal help
In his evidence to the Committee, Dr Drake highlighted how existing legal regulations can prevent university law clinics and not-for-profit organisations from providing practical assistance to people who need it, even where qualified and experienced legal professionals supervise their work.
One particular example concerns the small claims track in the County Court, which handles claims of up to £10,000 and is intended to be accessible to people without legal representation.
Although advice organisations can help clients understand their cases, existing restrictions on conducting litigation mean they cannot necessarily assist with preparing or progressing claims, unless they have the appropriate authorisation.
This can leave individuals facing businesses represented by experienced lawyers without the practical support they need to present their cases effectively.
The Committee specifically referenced Dr Drake’s evidence on this issue, noting that people without legal representation can struggle to distinguish legally relevant information from matters of personal importance, potentially making court hearings considerably longer.
The report concludes that the current regulatory framework can, in certain circumstances, leave the public without support they might otherwise be able to access.
Making legal help available earlier
The Committee also highlighted the importance of preventative legal support, recognising that people who cannot access timely advice may find their problems escalating into more serious and costly difficulties.
University law clinics and not-for-profit advice organisations can play an important role in helping people recognise and address legal problems early, before they develop into court cases or contribute to wider difficulties involving housing, employment, debt and family life.
The report recommends that the Government review regulatory barriers affecting these organisations, allowing them to provide more accessible and affordable services while maintaining appropriate protections for the public.
“The University of Manchester Justice Hub welcomes the Justice Committee’s report, Access to Justice: Access to Legal Services,” said Dr Drake. “We support its call to change the rules governing legal services so that they focus on the work being done and the risks to people using those services, making the structure of legal services regulation simpler and reviewing the barriers to the provision of low-cost not-for-profit services.”
“As I explained in my evidence to the Committee, the current rules can limit the help that university law clinics and not-for-profit organisations can offer, even when qualified legal professionals supervise the work. This is a particular problem when helping people with small claims in court and can make it harder for them to get the legal help they need.”
The Justice Committee’s report makes four principal recommendations, including establishing a national legal service modelled on NHS 111, securing additional funding to tackle unmet legal need, reforming legal services regulation and improving access to civil litigation funding.
Dr Drake’s evidence was submitted as part of a wider contribution to the inquiry alongside organisations including AdviceUK, Advicenow and the Law Centres Network.