For a mollusk to build its shell, it uses brittle chalk – crystalline calcite – which must take in other materials to make the chalk stronger. That process of incorporation has long been a mystery – one that Professor Lara Estroff has been working on for her entire career.
“How is it that biology is able to use these relatively cheap but fragile building blocks and turn them into structural materials? How do we reconcile the really well-ordered, beautiful regularity of a crystal with these disruptors?” said Estroff, part of a team from Cornell and the Pacific Northwest National Laboratory (PNNL) that has found answers in new research.
The work, published Nov. 20 in Science Advances, zooms into the surface of crystals to measure how they incorporate nanoparticles to change their properties, discovering and quantifying new dynamics in the process. The team created a predictive model for the incorporation of different types of fluorescent silica nanoparticles – known as “Cornell dots,” or “C dots” – that can be given varied functions based on their surface chemistry. The team verified the model with calcite as it incorporated the C dots, and the fluorescence allowed them to quantify the process with 3D microscopy.
The research will accelerate the exploration of new materials with novel, useful properties, and has implications for understanding foundational chemical processes such as catalysis.
“If we understand the design principles, we can apply them to generate better functional materials,” said Estroff, the Herbert Fisk Johnson Professor of Industrial Chemistry in the Cornell Duffield College of Engineering. “It’s exciting because the research has answered some very fundamental questions, thereby opening up new applications. This is also the first example that we know of where we have a predictive model for the inclusion of nanoscale objects into crystals, with quantifiable variables that we can then test directly with fluorescence-based imaging and quantification.”
“This was a fantastic project which built on what Cornell is best at: bringing together interdisciplinary groups to solve very important problems,” said co-author Uli Wiesner, the Spencer T. Olin Professor of Engineering in Duffield Engineering and professor of design tech in the College of Architecture, Art and Planning. “It was a pleasure to be part of the team and to contribute with our nanoparticle knowhow.”
Estroff’s lab provided expertise on crystal formation and Wiesner’s lab on nanoparticles and surface chemistry; Elias Nakouzi, materials scientists at PNNL, created the model, and his lab carried out surface characterization studies, which included the use of cutting-edge 3D atomic force microscopy. Mingyi Zhang, former postdoctoral researcher at PNNL, now an assistant professor at University of Oklahoma, is first author.
The model took cues from Nakouzi’s previous work with nanoparticles. This research found that, in solution, two nanoparticles approaching each other from a distance will begin to orient themselves toward each other – with the layers of fluid they move through playing a significant role. The researchers applied the same principle to nanoparticles as they approach crystals and were able to quantify the major factors that impact incorporation. This included the diffusion of nanoparticles in the solution, the binding energy based on the surface chemistry of the nanoparticle, and the crystal’s rate of growth, parameters that had been considered before. But for the first time it also highlighted the importance of the work or energy it takes the nanoparticles to get through the water layers to the crystal’s surface.
“Previously, the field was very focused on optimizing the binding, but we found that in order to make correct predictions, you have to take into consideration this work that it takes for a particle to get from solution onto the crystal surface,” Estroff said. “This has added a whole new design concept that turns out to be very important.”
Estroff said using the model to make predictions will have a huge impact on how researchers in her field run experiments.
“Previous studies almost always focused on the binding step, and for us, it has always been very empirical: We try this and it works; we try that and it doesn’t work,” she said. “Now we can make more accurate predictions and then verify.”
The researchers also debunked assumptions about the strongest binding agents in calcite: They’re not carboxylic acids but amines. The discovery provides new insight to understanding biomineralization, the process by which organisms use calcite to form shells.
“Amines were better at getting through the water layer,” Estroff said. “That was a big aha moment. The whole community has been fixated on these carboxylic acids, but because we’ve thought of this problem from a different perspective, we’ve uncovered this other chemistry that we don’t entirely understand.”
Future research will explore that chemistry, as well as how the simultaneous incorporation of different nanoparticles impacts the properties of the material. A particularly relevant application may be in creating new composites and adhesives.
The work is part of a long-term project, funded by the U.S. Department of Energy, to explore biohybrid nanomaterials. Estroff and Wiesner have collaborated on these materials for more than a dozen years, with Nakouzi joining three years ago.
“None of us could have done this by ourselves, but working together we were able to tackle this longstanding problem,” Estroff said. “That’s satisfying.”
Co-authors include Kuan-Ting Liu, Ph.D. ’26; Dong June Jang, Ph.D. ’26; Victorien J.B. Bernat, M.S. ’25; Kavli Institute postdoctoral researcher Ying Xia; Dongsheng Li, Zihua Zhu and Jaehun Chun of PNNL; and Hsin-Mei Kao of the University of Oregon.